The Economist Aug 10th 2013 by The Economist

Author:The Economist
Language: eng
Format: mobi
Tags: News, The Economist
Publisher: The Economist
Published: 2013-08-09T04:17:46+00:00

* * *

This article was downloaded by calibre from http://www.economist.com/news/europe/21583311-once-strictly-conservatives-traditional-dress-becoming-cool-lederhosen-boom/print

| Section Menu | Main Menu |

| Next | Section Menu | Main Menu | Previous |

* * *

Turkish politics

Justice or revenge?

Harsh verdicts are handed down in the Ergenekon trial

Aug 10th 2013 | ISTANBUL |From the print edition

IT WAS meant to be an irreversible leap forward for Turkish democracy. But the verdicts handed down on August 5th at the close of the five-year Ergenekon trial against some 275 alleged coup-plotters among the army and its allies left many believing the country had moved in the opposite direction.

Prosecutors gave Ilker Basbug, a respected former chief of the general staff, and 18 others life sentences for conspiring to overthrow Turkey’s mildly Islamist Justice and Development (AK) party. Of the 256 other defendants, including lawyers, journalists, and academics, 21 were not convicted. The verdicts will be appealed.

The Ergenekon case rests on the argument that the generals had created a huge dirty-tricks department to discredit AK. Their alleged plans, which included blowing up mosques and murdering Christians, sound credible when set against their record of sponsoring squad killings of dissident Kurds and of serially torturing and jailing thousands of other purported enemies of the state. Defanging the generals remains Mr Erdogan’s biggest achievement so far. And there is no denying that this week’s convictions send a clear message about the fate that awaits those who plot such mischief in future.

However, the trial, which took place in a purpose-built courtroom outside Istanbul, has been plagued by controversy from the start. Even Recep Tayyip Erdogan, the prime minister, whom the army sought to boot out as recently as 2007, has aired misgivings about its conduct. These grew after Mr Basbug’s arrest in 2012. The general has been credited with supporting the government’s moves to reach a political settlement with the Kurds. “History will not excuse those who call Basbug a member of a terrorist organisation,” Mr Erdogan recently declared. Mr Basbug’s daughter, Feride, called the verdict “a comedy”. Kemal Kilicdaroglu, the leader of Turkey’s pro-secular main opposition, the Republican People’s Party (CHP), believes prosecutors were seeking not justice, but revenge.

Defence lawyers have long claimed that much of the evidence against their clients was either fabricated or doctored. Western diplomats who have followed the case agree that there are enough holes in the case to compromise its legitimacy. Some detect the hand of Turkey’s most influential Muslim fraternity, the Gulenists, so-called after their leader, Fethullah Gulen, a steely imam who lives in self-imposed exile in America. Mercilessly hounded by the generals, the Gulenists have thrived under a decade of AK rule. They are said to have infiltrated the police force and the judiciary in such large numbers that Mr Erdogan now sees them as a threat and is seeking to weed them out.

The public may well have been disposed to see the trial in a positive light, had it not been for Mr Erdogan’s increasingly authoritarian ways. These propelled the mass street protests that convulsed the country in June.

Download

Copyright Disclaimer:
This site does not store any files on its server. We only index and link to content provided by other sites. Please contact the content providers to delete copyright contents if any and email us, we'll remove relevant links or contents immediately.